ENGL C0856
Adult Learners of L&L
Prof. Barbara Gleason
Feb. 11, 2014
Selected Passages
from Adult Learners in Focus 2008
Please comment on the quoted passages below. What is your
reaction to the idea presented in the quotation? What questions come to mind?
Write freely but write clearly so that you produce a response that can be
voiced in class later.
“Over 26 million adults
in the U.S. currently have no high school diploma, more than 3 million have not
attended college and are earning less than a living wage, and over 8 million
have not attended college and speak little or no English.” (7)
Your response:
The first question that comes to mind after reading this is
why? In situations like this how can this issue be resolved? It seems that
blaming the government and state to implement better programs will in some way
be beneficial, but only partially. Right from the beginning it is a blame game:
first blame the students, who in turn blame their teacher for not making
materials interesting or lack of experience; who in turn blames their
principles for lack of training, then the blame is –passed on to the state
officials who have not implemented good programs for adequately training teachers,
so that they can raise attendance-hence academics- this blame will then go to
the federal government for not placing enough time, effort, and money into the
communities that are suffering where ultimately the crisis of high drop-out
rates occur.
The entire problem goes back in to funding and the
educational priorities of a community. The reoccurring cycle of not completing
high school depends on your community. If a community is not funded adequately
the hope of an education seems worthless and students have no other reason than
to leave. I believe to handle the
situation each community in a state should be funded equally giving students
coming out of the schools equal opportunities.
“The good news is that adults
are making up an ever larger share of the total enrollment in postsecondary
institutions. By 2004, adults made up approximately 43 percent of total
enrollment at community colleges (includes full-time and part-time).” (7)
Your response:
I feel that this is a good thing yes that many adults are
not giving up on educational opportunities, but in some case it is a little too
late. Some companies are looking for fresh faces to work with and age does play
a lot when it comes to achieving what needs to be learn.
“Nontraditional students—for example, those who have delayed enrollment in postsecondary
education, work full-time while enrolled, or have dependents other than a
spouse—were more likely than traditional students both to participate in
distance education and to be in programs available entirely through distance
education” (8)
This can be good and bad- good because they are now able to
finally complete their education in a setting that is more convenient for them,
however they are also missing out on one of the key aspects of learning, where
you have an opportunity to meet and discuss with new people and gather new
ideas.
"States vary significantly in their success in moving
students through this traditional educational pipeline. . . . But reliance on
and attention to the traditional educational pipeline alone will not be
enough.” (22)
Your response:
“The issue of declining numbers of high school graduates,
projected in a recent study by the Western Interstate Commission for Higher
Education (208), is yet another reason why a focus on the education of younger
populations will not be sufficient.” (23)
AND
“. . . 13.3 percent of the adult population
(26,455,554 individuals) . . . never completed high school. Many of these
adults may face basic literacy challenges as well. One way to help this
population is to address skills shortfalls through Adult Basic Education (ABE),
gain a high school credential by completing a GED, then enter postsecondary
study.” (24)
Your response:
Charlin, I'm glad to see you responding to these quotes. I agree with some of your comments. For example, I agree that funding of education does matter. But it also matters WHAT is being funded. WHAT curricula, WHAT programs. If funds are used for programs that don't support learning effectively, then those funds are not well spent.
ReplyDeleteThere are a few comments you make that I don't quite understand. You say that distance learning prevents adult students from meeting other people. That might or might not be true. In some online programs, people meet each other by online communications and sometimes they even meet briefly in person, when there is a requirement to do so. Online education (one form of "distance education" can allow people to meet but they meet in different ways than are common in brick and mortar classrooms.
Charlin, another comment you make is that it might be a little late for adults to go to school because employers are looking for youthful employees. That may be true in some cases. But it is not a reason for adults to avoid learning in formal educational programs. Even if there is age discrimination in the workplace, most adults still need to earn a living. They often have no choice. Another point to consider: improving job options is just one reason for formal learning. Adults may also broaden their mental horizons, become more fulfilled and enjoy their lives more, and become better at managing their personal finances, raising children, and participating in a democracy as citizens. There are many reasons for seeking an education.
ReplyDelete